End of Season Sale | Buy 2, Get 1 Free + Free Gifts 🎁

This $31 Jar Brings Dried-Out, Stiff Old Baseball Gloves (And Dad's Glove From The Garage) Back To Life In Minutes

By Wes Tolliver | The Sandlot Dispatch Last updated October 9, 2026 · 4 min read

The guy at the sporting goods store took one look at Dad's old glove and told me to buy a new one. $250.

My buddy who coaches Legion ball said, "Don't do that. I brought mine back for $31."

He was right.

You've tried the forum advice. Glove oil. Neatsfoot from the hardware store. Vaseline. Even the zip-lock bag in the sun.

And if you're STILL looking at a glove that's stiff as cardboard, laces you can't untie, and a pocket gone grey and dry...

The problem isn't your glove. It's what you've been using.

Most glove products go one of two ways. The thin oils soak right through and leave the glove heavy. The cheap ones look good for a few days, then you're right back where you started.

Tanner's Oath is different.

It goes on thin, stays where your cloth puts it, then buffs down under a natural wax.

Think of it like chapstick for your glove.

Dried-out leather comes back rich. Stiff fingers bend again. Dad's glove closes around a ball again, in about 10 minutes.

Over 122,000 people are using it instead of buying new.

Here's why it works when everything else fails:

Half-done before and after on a dried-out old baseball glove, blue tape down the middle

1It Actually Revives Dried-Out Leather (Not Just Shines It)

Every product I'd tried just made the glove look wet for a day. The thin oil soaked right through and left it heavy. The cheap conditioner was gone in a few days.

Tanner's Oath actually feeds the leather.

✅ Dried-out, grey, thirsty leather? Rich again.
✅ Fingers stiff as cardboard? Soft again.
✅ That dull, dusty look in the pocket? Gone.

It's made with cold-pressed hemp seed oil that works into the leather fibers, replacing the oils that years of sweat, infield dirt and a hot garage pulled out. Then the natural beeswax seals everything back in.

★★★★★Jason M."My dad’s old glove had been sitting in a box for probably 20 years. The leather was stiff and the palm looked completely dried out. I did one side first because I didn’t want to mess with the whole thing if it went wrong. Once I buffed it out, the difference was pretty obvious. Same old glove, same wear marks, it just looked alive again."

An untreated glove and a treated glove side by side on a dugout bench

2Works on Gloves, Catcher's Mitts, Laces, Bat Bags, All Your Leather (And the Boots Too)

Same day I did Dad's glove, I tested it on my son's.

A gamer that had spent all winter zipped in his bat bag? Alive again.

Then I tried it on:

✅ My daughter's fastpitch glove, put away dirty and wet after the last tournament
✅ My old catcher's mitt, stiff from years on a shelf
✅ Rawhide laces so stiff you couldn't untie them
✅ A pair of boots that were "stiff, dried out and dull"

One jar. Leather and wood. No need to buy separate products.

★★★★★Eric T."I’ve had this Rawlings since high school and it was getting to the point where I thought I’d finally have to retire it. The leather had gone dull and the pocket felt dry as hell. Worked some of this into it and played catch with it afterward. The color came back and it loosened up without turning floppy. My son thought I had sent it out to get reconditioned."

Rubbing Tanner's Oath into the pocket of an old baseball glove with a cloth

3Takes 10 Minutes, Not a Season of Breaking In a New One (Or $250)

New glove$250 + a season to break in

Tanner's Oath10 minutes · $31

Here's the process:

1️⃣ Wipe the dirt off first
2️⃣ Rub a thin coat in with a cloth
3️⃣ Buff it dry
4️⃣ Done

No soaking. No zip-lock bag in the sun. No guessing what "sparingly" means. No new glove.

★★★★★Matt R."I was about ready to send my glove out for a full recondition because it had gotten so stiff around the heel and fingers. Tried this first. Took maybe ten minutes to work it in and wipe it down. Didn’t magically make it a new glove, which I didn’t want anyway. It just feels like my glove again."

Close-up of the glove pocket and lacing after buffing

4Results Show Up in Minutes (Not Weeks)

The old forum advice makes you wait:

"Oil it. Bag it. Leave it in the sun. Do it again next week."

Tanner's Oath shows results within minutes.

⚫ Dried-out, grey leather turns rich and alive
⚫ The stamping in the pocket stands out again
⚫ Stiff fingers go soft in your hands

My brother picked it up off the bench: "This isn't Dad's glove. Did you buy this?"

★★★★★Kevin D."Pulled my grandfather’s old glove out of storage and honestly thought the leather was too far gone to do much with. Put a little on and the leather started soaking it up almost right away. Ten minutes later it looked completely different. I’ve probably taken it out of the bag five times since then just to look at it."

Tanner's Oath jar with its natural ingredients laid out on a picnic table, a glove beside it

5All-Natural Ingredients (Safe on Your Hands and Your Kid's Glove)

Here's something most ball players don't know:

That Vaseline trick going around the forums? It's petroleum jelly. And the same forums will tell you it's easy to put a whole jar of it into a glove and make it heavy.

Tanner's Oath? 100% natural.

🟢 Cold-pressed hemp seed oil
🟢 Jojoba oil
🟢 Shea butter
🟢 Natural beeswax
🟢 Carnauba wax
🟢 Vitamin E

No petroleum. No harsh solvents. No chemical fumes.

And it buffs dry to the touch, so the ball isn't coming out of a greasy pocket. Got a tan glove? Do a small spot inside the wrist strap first, same as you would with any conditioner.

★★★★★Brian C."One thing I hate about some glove conditioners is that chemical smell they leave all over your hands. This doesn’t have that. I worked it into my glove at the kitchen table and it just had a mild waxy smell. No solvent stink, no greasy mess all over my hands afterward."

One jar of Tanner's Oath next to the bottles and tubs it replaces

6One $31 Jar = Every Glove in the House

Most ball families spend close to $60 trying to bring back one dried-out glove:

⚫ Rawlings Glovolium: $5
⚫ Pecard: $10
⚫ Franklin Dr. Glove: $10
⚫ Cannon: $16
⚫ Sarna: $17

Total: $58 (and the glove still feels the same)

Tanner's Oath: $31 for leather AND wood

I've used the same jar on all of it:

Dad's glove. My son's gamer. My daughter's fastpitch glove. The catcher's mitt. The leather bat bag. My boots. Grandpa's old bat on the shelf.

Cost per piece: A few dollars

★★★★★Scott H."I had two old gloves sitting in the bottom of my equipment bag that I hadn’t used in years because the leather had gotten so stiff. Did both of them with this and now they’re back in the rotation for playing catch with my boys. Still look broken-in and beat up like they should. They just don’t feel dried out anymore."

Before and after: the same old baseball glove, dried out and then revived

7Keep the Jar Even If You Return It (Try It Risk-Free)

30-day money-back guarantee.

Test it on every glove in the house.

⚫ Dad's glove that's sat in the garage for twenty years
⚫ Your kid's gamer that came out of the bag stiff
⚫ The catcher's mitt that got put away dirty and wet

If you don't love the results?

Return it. Get your money back. Keep the jar.

They even cover return shipping.

The Math That Matters

→ A new glove like Dad's: $250

→ A top-shelf glove for your kid: up to $400

→ Tanner's Oath: $31

Even at full price, it's a steal.

But right now:

👉 Buy 2, get 1 FREE
👉 FREE shipping
👉 FREE applicator brush
👉 30-day guarantee (keep the jar, get refunded, return shipping covered)

Each glove costs a few dollars.

Less than a round at the batting cage to bring a glove back.

And unlike the round, the results last.

Claim Buy 2, get 1 FREE + Free Shipping →30-day money-back guarantee

✔ 30-Day Guarantee✔ Free Shipping✔ 100% Natural

Right Now: Test It Risk-Free

You're covered by a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Test it on everything in the bat bag. If you're not thrilled, return it.

They'll refund you. Cover return shipping. You keep the jar.

That's Why Over 122,000 People Are Swearing By It

★★★★★ "A couple guys at the field laughed when I told them I bought something for my old glove. Then one of them picked it up after I finished and asked what I used on it. That was pretty much the end of the jokes."

★★★★★ "I was already looking at having my glove professionally reconditioned. Tried this before sending it out and ended up not bothering. The leather softened back up and the pocket still held its shape. Saved me the hassle and I didn’t have to hand my game glove over to somebody for a couple weeks."

★★★★★ "It’s basically like lip balm for an old glove. Mine was just thirsty. I worked a little into the palm and fingers and the leather soaked it right up. Wiped the extra off and that was it. No greasy glove, no weird shine."

★★★★★ "My dad told me not to waste my time on his old glove because it had been sitting forever. I cleaned it up and put this on it anyway. He picked it up the next day, started working the pocket with his hand, and asked if I had enough left to do another one."

So Here's Your Choice

Spend $250 on a new glove and a season breaking it in.

Or spend $31 today, do it in 10 minutes, test it risk-free for 30 days.

Over 122,000 people chose option 2.

I call it the best $31 I ever spent.

Click here now to claim buy 2, get 1 free + free shipping →

P.S. Ray W. said:

"This was my grandfather’s glove from the ’50s and I really didn’t want to do anything that would make it look restored or new. The leather had gotten dull and stiff from sitting all those years. After I worked this in, the brown came back and the leather felt a lot better, but every crease and worn spot is still there. That’s exactly what I wanted."

P.P.S. You're covered for 30 days. They refund you, cover return shipping, and you KEEP the jar. Literally zero risk. The only way you lose is doing nothing, and zipping a dried-out, stiff glove into the bag for another winter.