Why Your Saddle Keeps Going Stiff and Tacky
No boring leather science, promise. Just a quick barn story about the three little monsters living in your saddle, and the three heroes hiding inside a plain little jar.
Read the barn story“This one actually soaked in. I wiped it down after and there wasn't that coating left on the leather.”


The gremlins wake up.
Three tiny monsters live inside your saddle. They sleep while you ride, and the moment it goes back on the rack, they wake up. And honestly? They've found the perfect home. Leather stays soft because of the oil inside it. When it was still skin, it made that oil all by itself. But once it's made into a saddle, it can't make a single drop. So it's really easy to dry out. And that's exactly what these little monsters do to your saddle.

They throw a tack room party.
First, the Sipper sneaks into the middle of the leather and drinks up all the oil he can find. So now the middle of your fenders is bone dry. Then the Greaser grabs the drop of compound you rubbed in and smears it all over the top. It looks fed, but it never gets past the top. So the seat goes tacky and leaves a dark smudge on your jeans. And the Stiff-Arm? He grabs the dry middle of your fender and won't let it bend. You won't notice him until your next ride. Then the saddle squeaks every step, you turn the stirrup with both hands, and your knees ache by the end of the ride.
So no, you didn't ruin it.
It's thirsty.
Every can of compound ends up the same way:

Dark and shiny. You think: there, it's fed.

The shine fades, and the stiffness creeps back in.

Greasy on top, dry in the middle. Hello again, stiff fenders.
Buy another can of compound? Same story, all over again.
The nightTanner's Oatharrives!




But this time, three heroes are waiting for the gremlins.

You open the plain little jar.
Your jar of Tanner's Oath showed up on your porch while you were out feeding the horses. You carry it out to the tack room, and it looks like any other jar on the tack store shelf. But open the lid and, surprise, there are three heroes hiding inside. Meet the Diver, made of hemp seed oil and jojoba oil. His one job is getting down into the dry middle of your fenders. Then there's the Softener, made of shea butter and vitamin E. Her job is making that leather soft again and keeping the oil fresh. And right behind them is the Keeper, made of beeswax and carnauba wax, whose one job is keeping that oil in. One job each. So there's no room left for the gremlins.

The heroes start work.
Same rack as always. But tonight, someone new is waiting. You wipe the saddle clean and brush one thin coat onto the seat and fenders. The moment Tanner's Oath touches the leather, the Diver goes to work. He slips right past the top and down into the dry middle, where the bending happens. That's the spot the compound never reached. The Softener follows him down and makes the leather soft and supple again. Give them about ten minutes to soak in. Up top, the Keeper uses his superpower: he closes the door behind them, so the oil stays in. Then you buff it with a dry rag. Whatever the leather didn't drink wipes right off, so nothing's left on top to come off on your jeans.

The party's cancelled.
It's the middle of the night, when the party usually starts. The gremlins come out looking for oil to steal. The Sipper goes for the middle of the fender. Nothing. The Keeper is sitting right on top of it, so the oil just stays put. The Greaser looks for something sticky to smear around, but it's all been buffed dry. Nothing on top anywhere. So one by one, the Keeper puts them to bed.

And the Stiff-Arm?
Three thin coats this week, ten minutes each. Now it's Saturday. The Stiff-Arm tries to grab your fender one more time, but it bends right out of his hands. You throw the saddle on, and the fender swings over your knee, soft and easy. You turn the stirrup with one hand. No squeak. And when you get off after the ride, your knees don't ache, and for the first time in ages, there's nothing on your jeans.

Tanner's Oath Wood & Leather Salve
Packed by hand
Three heroes. Zero grease.

The Diver
Hemp seed oil and jojoba oil. They get past the top and down into the dry middle, where the bending happens.

The Softener
Shea butter and vitamin E. They make the leather soft and supple again and keep the oil fresh.

The Keeper
Beeswax and carnauba wax. They seal the oil in, so it buffs dry and nothing comes off on your jeans.
Six natural ingredients. One job each.
Our three heroes are made of six natural ingredients, two each. Here's every one of them, and what it does for your saddle.

Hemp seed oil
The DiverSoaks into the thirsty leather and gets down into the dry middle, where your fenders bend.

Jojoba oil
The DiverThin, so the leather drinks it instead of wearing it on top. It goes in with the hemp seed oil.

Shea butter
The SoftenerMakes the leather soft and supple again, so the fenders swing easy and stop fighting your leg.

Vitamin E
The SoftenerKeeps the oils fresh in the leather, so they don't go off while they do their work.

Beeswax
The KeeperSeals the oil in once it's soaked down, so it stays where your saddle needs it.

Carnauba wax
The KeeperHelps it buff dry to a soft sheen, with nothing left on top to come off on your jeans.
Turns out, lots of saddles had gremlins.
Other ways to fight the gremlins.
| Tanner's Oath | Neatsfoot compound | Saddle soap | Mink oil paste | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gets down into the dry middle | ✓ | ✕Soaks the top | ✕Only cleans | ✕Too heavy |
| Buffs dry, nothing on your jeans | ✓ | ✕Goes tacky | ✓ | –Can be greasy |
| No dye, its own color comes back | ✓ | ✕Can go dark | ✓ | –Can darken |
| Nothing petroleum based | ✓ | ✕Blended | –Check the label | –Check the label |
Goodbye, gremlins.
“Tested it underneath first”
“I was really hesitant to put anything on this saddle because it's such a light color. Neatsfoot darkened my old one pretty badly, so I tested this underneath first where you wouldn't see it.”
“My mom's saddle”
“This was my mom's saddle, and it had been sitting in her barn for almost 30 years. I honestly thought the leather was too far gone…”
“Still looks good”
“It's been about four months now and the leather still looks good and feels conditioned.”
A few more barn questions.
Because all of those either clean the top or sit on the top. And a greasy top over a dry middle is exactly the home the gremlins love. Tanner's Oath puts thin oil into the middle and wax over it to keep it in.
It has no dye and it goes on thin. Very dry leather can deepen a little with any conditioner, so try a little under the skirt first and look at it the next morning.
Yes, Western or English. Use a little less on fine English leather. It's for smooth, finished leather, so not for suede or roughout.
Not if you go thin and buff it. The Keeper seals the oil in and the rest wipes right off. If it still feels tacky, just buff it again.
Then just send it back. You've got 30 days to try it, and if you don't love it, you get all your money back.
Clean the saddle and let it dry. Brush on one thin coat, wait about ten minutes, then buff off the extra with a dry rag. Don't forget the underside of the fenders. A whole saddle takes about 10 to 20 minutes.
Scratch the horseshoe.
Everyone who reads all the way to the end gets a little Black Friday gift. Just drag your finger across the card.